Skip to main content

JK Plumbing

Water Heater Replacement in San Francisco: How Much Space Do You Actually Get Back?

Usually the closet, not the tank footprint — around four to six square feet of floor in a typical San Francisco flat, and only if the new unit goes somewhere else. JK Plumbing handles water heater replacement across San Francisco and Daly City. Call (415) 359-4588.

By Alik, Owner & Master Plumber · Last updated November 2026

50-gallon water heater filling a hallway closet in a San Francisco flat before replacement

How much usable space does losing the tank actually free up?

Less than the brochures imply and more than you’d guess, depending on one decision.

The tank itself isn’t the number. A 50-gallon tank is roughly 20 to 22 inches across. Its actual footprint is about two and a quarter square feet — which sounds disappointing until you remember you were never able to use the rest of the closet either.

The closet is the number. What you reclaim is the enclosure built around the tank: typically 24 by 30 inches, sometimes 30 by 30, which is four to six square feet of floor. More importantly it’s floor-to-ceiling, so in storage terms you’re recovering a usable cupboard rather than a patch of floor.

A wall-mounted tankless unit is genuinely small. Rinnai’s indoor models in its Value Series measure 22.95 inches tall by 14.04 inches wide by 9.27 inches deep and weigh about 46 pounds. That’s roughly the volume of a kitchen wall cabinet, mounted at head height.

But here’s the decision that determines everything. If the tankless unit goes back into the same closet, you gain the floor and the lower half of the space — useful, not transformative. You only reclaim the closet properly if the new unit moves to a different wall, typically an exterior one. So the honest version of the answer is: converting frees up a bit of space; relocating frees up the closet.

For a flat in the Sunset or the Mission where storage is the scarcest commodity in the building, that distinction is worth more than the energy-efficiency argument most of the industry leads with.

Can a small flat run on a tankless unit?

Almost certainly yes — but the question is usually asked backwards. The constraint is rarely the size of the flat. It’s the gas supply.

A whole-house tankless unit runs to 199,000 BTU per hour at full fire, against roughly 40,000 for the tank it’s replacing. Natural gas carries about 1,000 BTU per cubic foot, so that unit wants in the region of 199 cubic feet per hour delivered to it — and whether your building can deliver that depends almost entirely on how far the gas has to travel.

The sizing tables in the manufacturer’s own manual make the problem obvious. Three-quarter-inch pipe carries about 273 cubic feet per hour over a ten-foot run — comfortably enough. Over a hundred-foot run, the same pipe carries 79. One-inch pipe manages 514 at ten feet and 148 at a hundred.

Read that again, because it’s the whole issue: at a hundred feet, even one-inch pipe falls short of a single full-fire tankless unit. And a hundred feet is not unusual in a San Francisco flat where the meter sits at the front of the building and the water heater is at the back, or two floors up.

Three things actually decide feasibility:

The run length from the meter. Measured along the pipe, not across the floor plan. This is the variable that most often turns a straightforward conversion into a bigger job.

Total connected load. The tankless unit shares the meter with the furnace, the range and possibly a dryer. The building’s existing gas service was sized for a 40,000 BTU water heater, not a 199,000 BTU one, and in a multi-flat building the meter may need upgrading through the utility — which runs on the utility’s schedule, not yours.

Whether a smaller unit fits the household. A one-bathroom flat with one occupant does not need 199,000 BTU. Lower-output models exist at 150,000 and 180,000, and sizing down honestly can be what makes the existing gas line workable.

So the answer we give on a quote visit is never a yes or no about the flat. It’s a measurement of the gas run and a look at the meter.

Where can the vent legally terminate in a San Francisco flat?

This is the constraint that kills more conversions in this city than gas sizing does, and it’s almost never mentioned until someone is standing in the flat.

A tankless unit needs a sealed vent through an exterior wall, and that termination has clearances it must hold. From the same manufacturer documentation, under the national fuel gas code: 12 inches from an operable window or door, 12 inches from a non-mechanical air supply inlet or another appliance’s combustion air inlet, 6 feet from a mechanical air supply inlet, 12 inches above grade, 7 feet above a paved sidewalk or driveway, and 24 inches to an opposite wall or parapet.

Now put that in a San Francisco flat.

The light well is the problem. Buildings here sit on 25-foot lots with little or no side setback, and the interior rooms of a flat frequently face a light well shared with the building next door. That 24-inch clearance to an opposite wall is a real obstacle in a shaft that may be four feet across — and the windows in that shaft belong to your neighbours.

Your neighbour’s windows count. The 12-inch clearance from an operable window doesn’t stop at your property. A vent terminal discharging beside someone else’s bedroom window is a problem whether or not it technically passes.

Your neighbour’s vent counts too. Terminals at the same level need 12 inches between them; terminals at different levels need 60 inches of vertical separation. If the flat above or below has already converted, their terminal is now an input to your design.

The front facade usually isn’t available. Between the sidewalk clearance, the entry steps and the fact that it’s the front of the building, street-facing termination is rarely the answer.

What this means practically: the vent path, not the plumbing, is what we’re assessing first. If a workable termination exists, the conversion is straightforward. If it doesn’t, a high-efficiency tank or a direct-vent replacement in the existing location is the better answer, and we’ll say so rather than engineering around a wall that was never going to work.

How does the old unit get out when it came in before the walls did?

Frequently it doesn’t — not in one piece.

A 50-gallon tank is about 20 inches across and five feet tall, it weighs 140 pounds or so empty, and it does not bend. In a flat where the closet was framed around it, or where a kitchen remodel in 1998 narrowed the hallway, the original route out no longer exists.

It gets drained first. Always, and completely. A full 50-gallon tank weighs over 500 pounds.

Then it comes out in pieces if it has to. The tank is cut down in place and carried out in sections. This is routine work rather than a sign something went wrong, and it’s considerably less disruptive than removing a door frame.

The route gets protected before anything moves. Treads, handrails, door casings and flooring. Moving steel through an occupied flat without covering the route is how bannisters get gouged.

The new unit is the easy half. At around 46 pounds, a wall-mounted tankless unit goes in through doorways that the old tank couldn’t come out of. That asymmetry is why removal, not installation, is what we measure for on the quote visit.

The same San Francisco hallway closet reclaimed as floor-to-ceiling storage after the tank was removed

Does the replacement have to go back in the same spot?

No — and a replacement is the one moment when relocating is cheap, because everything is disconnected anyway.

Relocating is worth it when the current position means a long flue run, an awkward service route, a tank sitting above finished living space with no drain, or when reclaiming that closet is the actual goal of the project.

What it involves: extending the water lines, the gas line, the vent and the condensate drain, plus a permit covering the new position. Note that a tank-to-tankless conversion is generally treated as a more involved permit class than a like-for-like swap — San Jose, for example, requires plan review for a conversion where a straight tank replacement can be permitted online. Confirm the current process with San Francisco DBI for your own address before assuming it’s a same-day permit.

The move we’d advise against is relocating a unit into a space that only just satisfies minimum clearances in order to free up storage. Minimums are minimums, not targets, and the next person to service it will be working in whatever you leave them.

What drives the cost when access is difficult?

We don’t publish figures, because a conversion in a flat with a short gas run and an easy exterior wall and one in a rear flat with a hundred-foot run and a shared light well are not the same job, and a number on a web page would be wrong for one of them.

What we price against:

  • Gas line work — the run length from the meter, whether the line needs upsizing, and whether the utility has to upgrade the meter.
  • Vent path — whether a compliant termination exists on an accessible wall, or whether the vent has to travel.
  • Removal difficulty — whether the old tank comes out whole or in sections, and how far it has to be carried.
  • Relocation — extending water, gas, vent and condensate to a new position.
  • Electrical — a tankless unit needs a power supply the old tank didn’t.
  • Condensate — a condensing unit produces acidic condensate that needs a drain route and sometimes neutralisation.
  • Permits — a conversion is a different permit class than a swap.

What you get from us is a written quote after someone has measured the gas run and looked at the wall. Call (415) 359-4588 and we’ll book the visit.

Where we work

Across San Francisco — the Mission, Noe Valley, Bernal Heights, Potrero Hill, Glen Park, the Sunset and the Richmond — plus Daly City, Brisbane, South San Francisco and down the Peninsula to Burlingame.

Most water heater replacement quotes in this city are written on the assumption of a garage, a short gas run and an exterior wall nobody shares. In a flat, all three assumptions are usually wrong, and finding that out on installation day is how a one-day job becomes a three-visit one. We measure first.

Frequently asked questions

How much usable space does losing the tank actually free up?
Typically four to six square feet of floor, floor-to-ceiling — the closet rather than the tank footprint, which is only about two and a quarter square feet. A wall-mounted tankless unit is roughly 23 inches tall, 14 wide and 9 deep. But you only reclaim the closet properly if the new unit relocates to another wall; leave it in the same closet and you gain the floor, not the cupboard.

Can a small flat run on a tankless unit?
Almost always, but the limit is the gas supply rather than the flat. A whole-house unit draws up to 199,000 BTU per hour against about 40,000 for a tank. Three-quarter-inch pipe carries enough over ten feet and nowhere near enough over a hundred — and even one-inch pipe falls short at a hundred feet. Run length from the meter, total connected load and honest sizing decide it.

How does the old unit get out when it came in before the walls did?
It gets drained, then cut down and carried out in sections. This is routine in flats where the closet was framed around the tank or a later remodel closed the original route. The new wall-mounted unit, at around 46 pounds, goes in through doorways the old tank could never have come out of — which is why removal is what we measure for.

Does a replacement need the same spot, or can it move?
It can move, and a replacement is the cheapest moment to do it since everything is already disconnected. Moving requires extending water, gas, vent and condensate lines plus a permit for the new location. A tank-to-tankless conversion is generally a more involved permit class than a like-for-like swap, so confirm the process with San Francisco DBI for your address.

What does the whole swap cost in a building with difficult access?
It depends on factors that vary enormously between flats, so we quote in writing after a visit rather than publishing a figure. The drivers are gas run length and any upsizing or meter upgrade, whether a compliant vent termination exists on an accessible wall, how the old tank comes out, relocation distance, the electrical supply a tankless unit needs, and the condensate drain.

Why does the vent location matter so much in a San Francisco flat?
Because clearances collide with the way this city is built. A terminal needs 12 inches from an operable window or door, 12 from a combustion air inlet, 6 feet from a mechanical air inlet, 7 feet above a sidewalk and 24 inches to an opposite wall. In a four-foot light well shared with the building next door, surrounded by neighbours’ windows and possibly their vent terminals, those numbers are what decide whether a conversion is possible.

Visit or Call Us

JK Plumbing
Adress:1008 Edwards Rd Burlingame, CA 94010
Phone: (415) 359-4588
Hours: Open 24 hours, seven days a week.
Serving San Francisco, South San Francisco, Daly City, Brisbane and the Peninsula.
CA License #1080266

All Categories